One of the significant issues the court had to decide was whether the convention on the continental shelf 1958, in particular whether article 6. North sea continental shelf, germany v denmark, merits. This may be contested in a particular case by a state denying its opposability to itself. Doc the northsea continental shelf cases revisited. In case of multinational treaties generally states which are not signed are not bound, except their behaviors shows it that they has implied consent to it, only than they would be bound by that treaty.
Cite as, international court of justice icj, analysis of north sea continental shelf cases federal republic of germany v. Status of islandsreference to the draft convention on the law of the sea article 121. Whether the countries, germany, denmark and netherlands, should adhere to the equidistance principle as a treaty law article 6, paragraph2 of the geneva convention of 1958 on the continental shelf or customary international law as an acceptable method to delimit the north sea continental shelf amongst the said parties. By the two special agreements respectively concluded between the kingdom of denmark and the federal republic of germany, and between the federal republic and. Jul 02, 2016 north sea continental shelf cases, icj reps, 1969, p. Analysis of north sea continental shelf cases federal republic of germany v. Reports 1969 netherlands and denmark had drawn partial boundary lines based on the equidistance principle ab and cd. North sea continental shelf cases, icj reps, 1969, p. In the north sea continental shelf cases 3 the international court of justice had the opportunity of considering this phenomenon.
North sea continental shelf cases federal republic of germany v. Oscar mendoza is the owner of triumph tours, a travel agency business that has been experiencing difficulties in. Customary international law judicial application of the custom with reference to paquete habana lutos and north sea continent shelf cases. Geologically, continental shelf may be defined as the zone around the continent extending from the low water line to the depth at which there is usually a marked increase of declivity to greater depth. Pengantar hukum internasional north sea continental. For a custom to become binding as international law, it must. These cases concerned the delimitation of the continental shelf of the north sea as between denmark and the federal republic of germany, and as between. A continental shelf is a portion of a continent that is submerged under an area of relatively shallow water known as a shelf sea. On the continental shelf is binding for all the parties in this case that is to say. Exploration and exploitation of the marine natural resources are centred on the continental shelf. Analysis of the judgment of the international court of justice on the continental shelf contribution of the yugoslavitalian agreement to settlement of dispute in the north sea b. Both denmark and the netherlands submitted an individual dispute with germany to the icj involving claims to the north sea continental shelf.
See generally isi foigel, the north sea continental shelf case 1969 39 nordicjil. North sea continental shelf cases icj reports, 1969, p. The court observed that since the two countries abutted on a common continental shelf, the physical criterion was of no assistance for the purpose of delimitation. If the delimitation had been determined by the equidistance rule drawing a line each point of which is equally distant from each shore, germany would have received a smaller portion of the resourcerich shelf relative to the two other states.
North sea continental shelf case federal republic of. It is the above analysis which is relevant, not the straight comparison between the total number of states in existence and the number of parties. This is the first year that the north sea industry has cost the exchequer more than it has contributed. The north sea continental shelf cases 1969 provide one of the few instances where the icj has provided a detailed analysis and overview of the existence and requirements of customary international law. Federal republic of germany v denmark and netherlands. North sea continental shelf federal republic of germanynetherlands. Germanys north sea coast is concave, while the netherlands and denmarks coasts are convex.
North sea continental shelf nmea 08 pdf cases 1969 i. Generality widespread and representative participation, consistency virtually uniform practice and duration long duration of practice not necessary. An analysis of the aegean disputes under international law. The north sea nitro pdf professional v7 5 0 22 incl serials which appertain to each of themwith the exception of those. For a custom to become binding as international law, it must amount to a settled practice and must be rendered obligatory by a rule requiring it. All the case studies for this present work are from the norwegian continental shelf ncs, particularly, from the north sea and the norwegian sea areas, see fig. An economic analysis of the use of the dutch north sea. North sea continental shelf cases case importance state practice objective element of customary law requires. In his dissenting opinion in the north sea continental shelf cases judge. Whether the countries, germany, denmark and netherlands, should adhere to the equidistance principle as a treaty law article 6, paragraph2 of the geneva convention of 1958 on the continental shelf or customary international law as an acceptable method to delimit the north sea continental shelf. North sea continental shelf cases summary public international. Overview of the case these cases concerned the delimitation of the continental shelf of the north sea as between denmark and the federal republic of germany, and as between the netherlands and the federal republic, and were submitted to the court by special agreement.
This paper reflects the icjs notable decision in not laying any applicable principle and rules of international law on the delimitation of the north sea continental shelf between the disputing coastal states. An agreement on further prolongation of the boundary proved difficult because denmark and netherlands wished this prolongation to take place based on. Sambrailo equity in the north sea continental shelf cases t. North sea continental shelf cases the fact that a state honours obligations because they are signatories to treaties does not indicate that they consider the rule part of customary international law.
Principles applicable in the delimitation of continental shelf 1. Structural and stratigraphic evolution of the mid north sea. Sep, 2017 north sea continental shelf cases icj reports, 1969, p. The north sea is a marginal sea of the atlantic ocean located between great britain england and scotland, denmark, norway, germany, the netherlands, belgium and france. Germany v denmark and the netherlands 1969 icj 1 were a series of disputes that came to the international court of justice in 1969. In the north sea continental shelf cases, the court deduced from the existing customary international law principles that continental shelf delimitation must be the object of agreement between the states concerned and that such agreement must be arrived at in accordance with equitable principles and the actual rules of law. The north sea continental shelf cases papers in the ssrn. On 1 december 1964, the federal republic of germany and the netherlands concluded an agreement for the partial delimitation of the boundary near the coast. An analysis of negotiations abhilasha mittal1 abstract the main purpose of this paper is to understand the reasons for the failure of the negotiations between the three states i.
North sea continental shelf federal republic of germany. Case concerning the continental shelf tunisialibyan arab jamahiriya international court of justice reports 1982 i. Latest developments north sea continental shelf federal. Essay on north sea continental shelf case 1506 words. North sea continental shelf, germany v denmark, merits, judgment, 1969 icj. Quantitative content analysis of the united nations seabed. This case was decided on by the icj in 1982 with a vote of 104. On 9 june 1965, the federal republic of germany and denmark. Cases previous next overview of the case institution of proceedings written. Parties in case of unanimous recommendations by the commission would not serve a useful. Analysis of north sea continental shelf cases federal.
North sea continental shelf federal republic of germany v. The delimitation of maritime boundaries may create overlapping claims requiring maritime boundary delimitation. The north sea oil and gas sector became a net drain on the uks public finances for the first time in 2016, carbon brief analysis shows. Jan 19, 2014 north sea continental shelf case cindy llanes. North sea continental shelf cases federal republic of germanydenmark, federal republic of germanynetherlands i.
Table of contents north sea continental shelf cases federal republic of germanydenmark. Mar 17, 2020 interpretation of newly acquired seismic and legacy well data has led to a greater understanding of the upper paleozoicrecent geological evolution of the mid north sea high mnsh, an underexplored region of the north sea. North sea continental shelf cases essay, law europe. The position of granitecored blocks controlled the distribution of devonocarboniferous highs and basins before variscan uplift led to peneplanation and the creation of.
Summaries north sea continental shelf federal republic of. North sea continental shelf case germany v denmark and the netherlands 1969. Delimitation of maritime boundaries between adjacent states. Much of these shelves has been exposed during glacial periods and interglacial periods. In the north sea continental shelf cases, the parties expressly reserved to themselves the right to choose the delimitation methods, call. The dispute, which was submitted to the court on 20 february 1967, related to the delimitation of the continental shelf between the federal republic of germany and denmark on the one hand, and between the federal republic of germany and the netherlands on the other. The jurisprudence of the north sea continental shelf cases sets out the dual requirement for forming customary international law state practice objective element and opinio juris subjective element. North atlantic coast fisheries arbitration united kingdom v. An epeiric or shelf sea on the european continental shelf, it connects to the ocean through the english channel in the south and the norwegian sea in the north. Initially both denmark and netherlands submitted an individual dispute with germany to the icj international court of justice involving claims to the continental shelf. Give the name of this problem and then a case in which it was evidences.
They involved agreements among denmark, germany, and the netherlands regarding the. North sea continental shelf cases oxford university press. North sea continental shelf case federal republic of germany denmark. The north sea continental shelf case, 1969 parties to the suit. Federal republic of germany v netherlands north sea continental shelf cases, decided in 1969, were the first cases concerning the delimitation of maritime zones seaward of the territorial sea. North sea continental shelf federal republic of germanynetherlands cases previous next overview of the case institution of proceedings. Sediment grainsize distribution analysis at the shallow. The foregoing analysis leads to the conclusion that the provisions of article 6, paragraph 2, of the geneva convention on the continental shelf, and more especially the equidistance rule, have attained the identifiable status of a general law. Pengantar hukum internasional north sea continental shelf case 1. Case concerning the continental shelf tunisialibyan arab. Refworld analysis of north sea continental shelf cases.
The shelf surrounding an island is known as an insular shelf the continental margin, between the continental shelf and the abyssal plain, comprises a steep continental slope. A summary and case brief of north sea continental shelf cases federal republic of germany v. Icj north sea continental shelf cases, separate opinion of judge fouad ammoun, icj rep. The application of the equidistance method could not, in particular circumstances of the case, lead to an equitable result. Icj north sea continental shelf cases, separate opinion of. North sea continental shelf cases decisions of the international court of justice, though relatively fav in number, are generally the subject of extensive commentary and analysis. The separate and dissenting opinions of individual judges, which lak the authonity of the courts pronouncements. Introduction the north sea, a marginal sea lying between the eastern coast of great britain and the northwestern part of continental europe, has featured prominently in european history. Quantitative content analysis of the united nations seabed debate. These two claims were joined by the icj and were decided as one case. The truth about mobile phone and wireless radiation dr devra davis duration. Continental shelf meaning, principle and case laws.
North sea continental shelf cases federal republic of. It elaborated the criteria necessary to establish state practice. Federal republic of germany v denmark and v netherlands, 1969 icj rep 3. Dec 22, 2017 the truth about mobile phone and wireless radiation dr devra davis duration. Continental shelf issues in the yellow sea and the east china. North sea continental shelf, germany v denmark, order. Exploitation of the german continental shelf of 22 january 1964, reproduced in countermemorial submitted by the government of the kingdom of denmark icj pleadings vol i 157, 244. Proceedings joined with north sea continental shelf federal republic of germanynetherlands on 26 april 1968 overview of the case these cases concerned the delimitation of the continental shelf of the north sea as between denmark and the federal republic of germany, and as between the netherlands and the federal republic, and were submitted to the court by special agreement. Netherlands judgment of 20 february 1969 fakta hukum pihak yang bersengketa dalam kasus ini adalah negara republik federasi germany dengan denmark dan belanda persengketaan ini mengenai penentuan batas landas kontinen di laut utara sengketa ini. Feb 24, 2007 qatarbahrain decision of march, 2001, supra note 199, paras. Methodology and a continental shelf case study volume 24 issue 3 r.
The concept of opinion juris analyzed by the dissent is in consonance with the. Delimitation of continental shelf legal service india. International court of justice icj published on by oxford university press. North sea continental shelf case federal republic of germany v denmark and v netherlands citation. Ratification after signature is required to consequently make that party liable to obey the treaty. Manifest intent and the generation by treaty of customary. It is in respect of the delimitation of the continental shelf areas lying beyond and to. Generally continental shelf is the shallow part of sea bottom adjacent to land. This clip provides an introduction to the judgment of the international court of justice in the cases between the federal republic of germany and denmark and the netherlands relating to the north.
1545 1135 843 1059 506 1315 896 23 32 804 1319 1222 1333 882 642 191 1109 267 31 981 763 46 1484 1237 914 935 191 878 1361 339 9 1457 1212 413 1374 626 1291 578 1443 406